you need to get bulb #PC 194
Canadian Tire did a lookup and got me a bulb that didn't fit, Napa did a lookup and got me a different bulb that didn't fit, then the Dodge dealer did a lookup and got me a 194 bulb that didn't fit. Apparently, in the 95's at least, only the high beam and cruise indicators are PC194s (the grey sockets), the rest (black sockets) are smaller and turned out to hold Mitsubishi part MB066068 (hurray for KW Mitsubishi!) which fits.
I also got a cluster out of a junker yesterday and scored many more bulbs, including one for an "O/D Off" indicator I don't have which is different yet again. Good thing too, when I was putting in the Mits bulb tonight I thought to meter out the rest and found three more that were gone... damn my dash is bright now.